Aisle 4 at the Stop and Shop: Where Lesbians Go to Pick Up Men

Allston shopping center: Super Stop & Shop, Go...
Image by Chris Devers via Flickr

Here is a little story I read in January 2010 during the residency of the Solstice MFA at Pine Manor College. Some of you heard me read it aloud, but others have not. Enjoy, or enjoy again: “Aisle Four at the Stop and Shop: Where Lesbians Go to Pick Up Men.”

“Now there’s a picture,” he says to me, leaning over his shopping cart, “Look at you holding your Dunkin’ Donuts coffee cup in one hand…” and then he points to the coffee-maker box I’m holding up with the other. I shrug my shoulders, perhaps begin to explain, you see, I’m the poster-child for caffeine addiction. We are in the Stop and Shop on a Friday night. He’s a youngish-looking bald man with blue eyes and a smile forming on his mouth. I look down into his shopping cart for clues. His cart is full of Nature’s Promise and Kashi products, expensive teas (no Lipton’s.) I mentally note the lack of red meat, of any meat. I look back to his eyes.

“Guess you caught me in my addiction,” I say. Thank god I’d thrown some zucchini and summer squash into my own shopping cart, some fresh spinach, enough vegetables to hide the deli-sliced roast beef and Genoa salami that lay at the bottom.  I am suddenly ashamed of my food. The Oreos are still visible. He holds up his Kashi cookies and says, “These are really good,” but I can’t believe that anything called a Kashi cookie will taste as good as an Oreo.  Then he talks about tea. He tells me at Starbucks he only orders tea. We are strangers who just happened to have met at this moment in aisle four of the Stop and Shop.

“Now, I make my own tea and bring it in a thermos to work,” he says, “I throw a slice of cheese on my own veggie sandwich I make at home, rather than buying one everyday at the Halfway Café.  I save a lot of money cooking for myself and I’ve lost ten pounds.”

I don’t tell him that at work today, I made three huge hamburger-filled tacos at the build-your-own taco bar and inhaled them into my body in less than five minutes. His eyes are twinkling at me, and I think he finds me attractive, somehow, even under the harsh lighting of the supermarket. I’m flattered, truly. I don’t tell him about my red-meat diet or that I sleep with women. I don’t see the need to come out to him regarding my love of hamburger or lesbians here in the coffee aisle at the Stop and Shop. Frankly, I’m enjoying his attention.

“So, you work around here?” I ask him. I continue to make small talk with a bald vegan man who eats Kashi.  Why do I continue to engage in conversation?

Or is a better question, “Why not?”

Do I want to get laid by a man?  I reach for a box of Triscuit crackers on the shelf opposite the coffee. “Oh yes, Triscuits,” I say a little too enthusiastically. Get laid the old fashioned way after twenty-five years of getting laid in alternative ways with or by women. Or have I been the one doing the laying? I lay women, I don’t say to him.  Am I hetero-curious all of sudden in middle-age? Maybe.  But no blow jobs. I place the Triscuits in my basket, over the Oreos. I never want another dick in my mouth. I don’t even really want a Triscuit. I’m not actually saying these things out loud to this man as we talk at the Stop and Shop. I’m saying something about Triscuit crackers, how I love the garlic ones best. While they are not Kashi-level-healthy, they are more presentable than the Cheez-its to which I am normally attracted.

“Did you see what you just did?” He’s laughing.

“What? Oh, you mean the Triscuits?”

“You were talking about coffee and then in a flash you were praising the merits of a Triscuit.”

“I’m on caffeine,” I say to him and furthermore, I only do oral sex with women, which I don’t say to him. When we do it together, create that sixty-nine, it’s better than any fucking Kashi cookie.  But right now, while I talk to Tim, who slipped in his name at some point, I do not expound upon my preference for a lesbian sixty-nine over a Kashi product.

It’s difficult to figure out his age but for some reason, I imagine he’s in his early thirties.  His skin is smooth and without wrinkles.  Finally I ask, “How old are you?’ and he surprises me by saying “Forty-nine.” I surprise him by telling him I’m forty-seven.  We stand in aisle four for a time ooh-ing and ahhh-ing over how young the other still looks.  Tim tells me he’s a fiction writer and independent film-maker and he doesn’t need to tell me he’s environmentally green.  One glance in the shopping cart makes that evident.

What a perfect guy I’ve met here in the supermarket on a Friday night. I, too, am a writer and into creative endeavors. I, too, enjoy talking and laughing. I, too, am apparently single and lonely enough on a Friday night to strike up a conversation with a stranger in aisle four. How perfect might we be together? But what would he think of all those plastic bottles I throw out with the trash? What would he think of the bloody roast beef I’ll be throwing in between two slices of white bread? Yeah, now those would be the problems between us should we have a date: the plastic bottles I throw in the trash and my roast beef sandwich — never mind the last twenty-five years of my life that I’ve spent sleeping with women.

Postscript to my encounter with Tim: I end up having tea and coffee with him a few times at a local Starbucks. He’s a very kind man, but aside from the fact that he is a heterosexual man and I am a lesbian, I can’t see him again because he keeps showing up with his black lace shoes untied. I am deeply freaked out that a grown man does not know enough to tie his shoes. There’s always that one thing.


  1. too funny, nee did mention the plastic bottles after your last visit. something about trying to kill the earth one bottle at a time. like she doesn’t litter the planet in her own way.

    i miss hearing your laughter every time you say the word kashi.


    • Suzanne, thanks for reading this. You WERE THERE they day I premiered it at the student reading last January. 🙂 I’m glad you were able to enjoy it again.

      And isn’t it strange that I try so hard to save my kitty cat but toss those plastic bottles out without any regard to killing the earth. I’m full of contradictions as you know.


      • Food shame. Oh god.

        So I was kind of a psycho at my Boy this week, but in a valid sort of way (long story). Still, I wanted to make it up to him, because it’s not really his fault he’s not as good at reading my moods as a chick would be.

        Remembering him making a passing comment once in a chocolate shop we stopped in for tap water (spontaneous post-surgery camping trip, and neither of us buy bottled water) about how dark chocolate (my favorite) is only so-so (whatever, Boy, that just means I don’t have to share), but peanut butter milk chocolate’s the best thing ever invented (hm… he has a fair point), I decided to make him chocolate cookies with peanut butter chips. You know, some good old fashioned, “Sorry I was kind of psycho, look, it’s cookies!”

        Apparently he’s decided gluten isn’t for him. These are definitely not healthy gluten-free cookies. These are stick-of-butter, fuckton of chocolate, god-knows-what-goes-in-a-peanut-butter-flavored-chip, COOKIES.

        I was mildly ashamed of my lack of health consciousness with my apology bribe.

        Except then I realized I didn’t have to share the cookies.


  2. Oh Cindy, I love the way you think! You made me laugh, and I needed to laugh today. I admire your courage. You have the courage to say things that others only think… 🙂


    • Geenie, I think you’ve had an especially hard day, from what I’m gathering, so if my post could make you laugh today, then at least I did one thing right. Oh, and I think Faye would agree that I will say pretty much anything – at least in my writing…Talk to you soon.


  3. OMG! I think I might be lesbian. Except for the part about wanting to have oral sex with a woman. Don’t worry about the plastic bottles. Somebody will come by and get those. You are too funny. That’s why I like you.


  4. cindy: thanks for sharing this story; it has brought back memories & unresolved questions for me, a bisexual man. the question of sexual attraction is a difficult one for me: I have seen men suddenly radiate the most tender and softest energy possible–out of the blue–and nice divorced mothers of three put on a t-shirt & leather jacket and go out for a date. The transformation of energy is mind-boggling–how does it happen? (if the question has any relevance to people’s lives). Transgressing taboo is incredibly erotic; but then there are people who fall in love just because they really enjoy each other. & then there was the older gentlemen I dated who was heartbroken by his divorce–he still loved his ex-wife. if we ever make peace about queerness, then maybe we can start thinking about the *really* dirty little secret: quality of relationship. Just a thought… RT


    • Eric,

      You are a lovely writer. I can tell just by your comment here. You are a lovely person. I can tell that, too. I looked briefly on your blog and became a subscriber. I look forward to your posts and your thoughts. You strike me as quite special. I’m not unresolved with my sexuality but I hear you and I admire your vigilance about your own sexuality and about the men – and women – in your life. I love the last line of your comment here: “…if we can ever make peace about queerness, then maybe we can start thinking about the “really” dirty little secret: quality of relationship. Brilliant. xoxoxo, Cindy


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.